The CMS Myth

May 2008 - Posts

  • Powering Corporate Content, Collaboration and Community with CMS


    Fellow CMS MythBuster Jeff Cram and I recently spoke to the Boston KM Forum, an energetic group of about 50 corporate knowledge managers from around New England. These are the folks in the trenches who make corporate content and data easily accessible for business advantage.

    Our topic: How the Enterprise Communications division of Siemens AG has embraced a global knowledge management (KM) portal delivering content, collaboration and community to thousands of Siemens employees worldwide. Oh, and how a mid-market CMS (Sitecore) sits at the center of it all. ISITE Design architected, designed and developed the portal, called BeFirst (“Be first in the market….”). We also employed the Google Search Appliance and some .NET programming.

    The portal has caught fire inside Siemens by elevating the traditional search/find/retrieve model to a flexible, innovative platform to connect peers globally, create ad hoc communities; publish blogs; rate document usefulness (the best ones bubble up to the surface); support tagging, taxonomy, faceted search and more. (Read a great recap of our presentation right here.)

    While we were there, it dawned on us: what were a couple of CMS-minded guys doing talking to a room full of experts in the quasi-academic discipline of knowledge management? These people live, eat and breathe strategies for indexing, tagging, archiving and searching knowledge assets inside law firms and biotech companies.

    This environment wasn’t always a natural fit for CMS, which used to play more at the fringes of KM, outside the inner circle of purpose-built applications that organize and categorize corporate knowledge. Not too long ago CMS, for lack of a better phrase, knew its place in the world.

    Flash forward to 2008, and there are legitimate reasons to discuss CMS and KM in the same sentence. Enterprise desires for flexible, accessible, social-networking driven intranets and portals have been met by the evolving capabilities of traditional CMS systems. Knowing a market opportunity when they see one, vendors scramble to add Web 2.0 (i.e. people-centric) features to their offerings (a smart strategy now that upstart widget makers and web 2.0 enablers are nibbling at their heels).

    Sticking to the theme of the CMS Myth, we should note that the Siemens BeFirst portal, for all of the technology behind it, would not have achieved business success without organizational buy-in – without staff in dozens of offices embracing the new paradigm for accessing knowledge assets and connecting with each other to achieve greater success.

    The lesson for content technology buyers is that CMS vendors should have a growing story to tell as they evolve and expand their capabilities, resulting in new options and new opportunities. CMS vendors have largely moved past traditional CM into document management and now social networking apps. Beyond that, integrated marketing suites; measurement and analytics tools; robust search and other tools give CMS an added relevance. All of which gives you the opportunity to inject CMS into new and unexpected places… and say things like, “Hello, knowledge management.”

     

     

  • Shifting from Content Management to Content Delivery

    Delivering great web experiences has always been the end goal of implementing a web content management system. CMS vendors, however, have historically only gotten you part of the way there.

    As vendors look to differentiate and provide more value, they are scurrying to deliver more ‘out of the box’ tools to deliver content and better overall user experiences. It’s important for the savvy web professional implementing content management to separate the features of content management from content delivery when approaching a vendor selection and implementation.  Let’s clearly distinguish the two camps.

    • Content Management features are the meat and potatoes of CMS and what customers have traditionally evaluated vendors upon. This includes features such as content repository, library services, workflow, WYSIWYG editors, meta data, image management, site replication, taxonomy, URL aliasing, user security and overall technical architecture. 
    • Content Delivery includes everything you do with that content on your website to deliver great user experiences.  This typically includes features such as dynamic templates, scheduled content, site search and multilingual controls. 

    The Next Generation of Content Delivery

    Buckle your seatbelts, because the world of content delivery is moving forward at light speed.  Much of the product innovation and customer demand is driven from the increase in online marketing and the pressure to deliver more results through the web channel.  Here are several types of content delivery features that can now be commonly included with a CMS platform.

    • Multivariate Testing:  Testing tools enable marketers to create dynamic landing pages and automatically test different combinations of content and images. This helps drive toward closed-loop optimization and the ability to rapidly determine the content that will drive the best results.  The level of sophistication among CMS vendors can vary greatly – from simple landing page management to integrated testing suites.
    • Social Media & Community:  It’s no surprise that CMS vendors have jumped into the social media scene with two feet.  Tools like forums, wikis, rss, tagging, blogs and user generated content are finding their way into CMS feature lists.  Some vendors have even shifted gears to position their entire offering as a ‘community platform.’ On the flip side, pure-play community platforms are emerging and backing into traditional CMS.
    • Behavioral and Content Targeting:   We all remember the rise and fall of personalization.  Those expensive portals of the past have been replaced by leaner and meaner technology that profiles users based on attributes such as onsite behavior, search keywords, referring site and geography.  Content can then be targeted and sites can (in theory) get smarter the more they learn about users and their behavior. Still in its infancy, content targeting is a true differentiator for the CMS platform that can get it right (or acquire the right technology).
    • Rich Media & AJAX:  We’ve definitely moved beyond static pages and content management vendors are getting more adept at providing video management and delivery tools and out of the box AJAX-driven widgets. 
    • Packaged Applications:  In some cases, we’re also seeing content management vendors start to package up some common applications such as calendars, membership application, intranet tools and more.  This is more common with vendors that are developing products around verticals.  

    Best of Breed vs. Integrated

    With CMS feature sets expanding and the lines blurring between different platforms, acquiring content delivery tools bundled with CMS is both an opportunity and a risk for organizations. 

    The right tools can greatly reduce development costs and speed up time to market. However, just because a CMS vendor has a specific feature does not mean it is best of breed or right for your organization.  In fact, more often than not, we’ve found these new features are usually far from enterprise class and are quick add-ons to support a new customer demand or market shift.  They can often leave you with an inflexible and inferior tool that can’t scale to meet your needs.

    In some cases the benefit of an integrated tool set may trump having the best possible technology.  In other situations, finding an open CMS that can easily integrate with off the shelf tools is a much better fit. The savvy CMS decision maker will look behind the marketing hype and take a holistic look at their web operations and user experience needs to determine how all the pieces need to fit together.

    Leave a comment and let us know how are you dealing with content delivery and what you expect from your CMS.