The CMS Myth

Measure Twice, Cut Once with Web CMS

Carpenters, of all people, have a great saying, one that everyone responsible for a CMS project should tattoo on their forearm, or at least write on their office wall in big red letters:  “Measure twice, cut once.” It’s just four simple words, but oh-so-rich in wisdom and rife with pragmatism.

Precision matters to carpenters. So their little saying about measuring and cutting clicks inside their brain every time they’re about to rip into a new sheet of plywood or saw a 2x4. It reminds them: you have one shot at getting it right, or it’ll cost you time and money.

And, just like it’s impossible to fix a botched cut (well, unless you can afford an endless supply of plywood, or if right angles don’t matter in the house you’re building) it’s similarly hard to straighten out a CMS initiative whose first few “cuts” are ill-measured or hastily accomplished.

Every web project manager has had one misadventure to know: long days/sleepless nights, plus an added tariff of missing your timeline, killing your budget, shedding your internal credibility and executive support --- and for some, shedding your job.

We continue to advocate that, to do CMS right, you need at the very least a vision, a plan, and a well-defined process  --remember, measure twice, cut once -- to deliver a successful CMS outcome. Early steps of a project may seem mundane or easy to bypass for efficiency’s sake – say, astutely defining visitor personas, or properly defining content taxonomy.  But keep in mind: these are your 2x4’s and plywood, so saw them at your peril.

Comments

 

Dean Peterson said:

Great words, Dave.

CMS poorly done, gives CMS a bad street rep.  Keep up the banner for web excellence using CMS.

March 20, 2008 10:32 PM
 

Adriaan Bloem said:

Yes... and no. Some may never get past the initial planning stages because they over-do it. It's all about balance... exactly as Jeff's earlier post about the team that should run these projects explains.

To illustrate: Dilbert's take on "measure twice, cut once" in web development about a week before your post: www.dilbert.com/.../dilbert2008031349276.jpg -- which, apart from the punchline, subtly references what happens if you spend too much time planning.

Either isn't good. That's why it's so hard to give advice that has universal appeal ;)

March 23, 2008 12:29 PM
 

Ron West said:

Is planning for a year a bad thing?  Well in my case - yes.  After planning starts and stops we now have no more budget to actually implement.  In some cases, if we had done less planning and "prototyped" a solution we would at least have something.  I am all about planning but I agree - how do you not get caught in the "too much" category?  Maybe another post about proper planning???

April 21, 2008 11:18 PM

Leave a Comment

(required) 
(optional)
(required) 
Submit

About David

A former 'CMS Insider,' David is relentlessly focused on the gap between vendor speak and customer adoption. In addition to keeping a keen eye on industry trends, he works with clients on the cultural and process implications of CMS that are so often overlooked.